Performance Creative / NYC

Performance creative agency in New York +20% avg. CVR, -30% avg. CPA

We produce performance creative for NYC brands running paid social, so your media team gets testable concepts weekly without building out a full in-house creative team.

Performance Creative / NYC

Performance creative agency in New York +20% avg. CVR, -30% avg. CPA

We produce performance creative for NYC brands running paid social, so your media team gets testable concepts weekly without building out a full in-house creative team.

Performance Creative / NYC

Performance creative agency in New York +20% avg. CVR, -30% avg. CPA

We produce performance creative for NYC brands running paid social, so your media team gets testable concepts weekly without building out a full in-house creative team.

Paid social formats designed for New York brands

New York runs some of the most saturated paid social feeds and highest CPMs in the country, so creative has to earn attention fast. We match formats to that pace, from hook-led videos built to stop cold traffic before the scroll continues to proof-heavy ads that close out higher-intent buyers.

Paid social formats designed for New York brands

New York runs some of the most saturated paid social feeds and highest CPMs in the country, so creative has to earn attention fast. We match formats to that pace, from hook-led videos built to stop cold traffic before the scroll continues to proof-heavy ads that close out higher-intent buyers.

Paid social formats designed for New York brands

New York runs some of the most saturated paid social feeds and highest CPMs in the country, so creative has to earn attention fast. We match formats to that pace, from hook-led videos built to stop cold traffic before the scroll continues to proof-heavy ads that close out higher-intent buyers.

Creative focused on stronger acquisition returns

Performance data guides every decision.

Control CAC pressure

Brands in New York compete for attention in expensive, crowded paid feeds. We sharpen hooks, offers, and value propositions to give each impression a stronger chance of turning into revenue.

Win higher-intent clicks

NYC shoppers are used to comparing options fast, with dozens of brands one swipe away. We use clear proof, product benefits, and sharper positioning to filter casual interest and bring more purchase-ready traffic into the funnel.

Maintain conversion quality

Buying power and motivations vary across New York audiences. We develop distinct message angles for different customer groups so broader reach doesn’t dilute relevance as campaigns scale.

Creative focused on stronger acquisition returns

Performance data guides every decision.

Control CAC pressure

Brands in New York compete for attention in expensive, crowded paid feeds. We sharpen hooks, offers, and value propositions to give each impression a stronger chance of turning into revenue.

Win higher-intent clicks

NYC shoppers are used to comparing options fast, with dozens of brands one swipe away. We use clear proof, product benefits, and sharper positioning to filter casual interest and bring more purchase-ready traffic into the funnel.

Maintain conversion quality

Buying power and motivations vary across New York audiences. We develop distinct message angles for different customer groups so broader reach doesn’t dilute relevance as campaigns scale.

Creative focused on stronger acquisition returns

Performance data guides every decision.

Control CAC pressure

Brands in New York compete for attention in expensive, crowded paid feeds. We sharpen hooks, offers, and value propositions to give each impression a stronger chance of turning into revenue.

Win higher-intent clicks

NYC shoppers are used to comparing options fast, with dozens of brands one swipe away. We use clear proof, product benefits, and sharper positioning to filter casual interest and bring more purchase-ready traffic into the funnel.

Maintain conversion quality

Buying power and motivations vary across New York audiences. We develop distinct message angles for different customer groups so broader reach doesn’t dilute relevance as campaigns scale.

Built beyond short-term NYC performance

CPMs in New York are already high, so chasing cheaper clicks brings in lower-quality buyers who don't stick around. We track who each piece of creative attracts, how those buyers behave after converting, and whether that quality holds as spend scales. That's what keeps your acquisition cost tied to stronger LTV, retention, and revenue quality as spend grows.

Built beyond short-term NYC performance

CPMs in New York are already high, so chasing cheaper clicks brings in lower-quality buyers who don't stick around. We track who each piece of creative attracts, how those buyers behave after converting, and whether that quality holds as spend scales. That's what keeps your acquisition cost tied to stronger LTV, retention, and revenue quality as spend grows.

Built beyond short-term NYC performance

CPMs in New York are already high, so chasing cheaper clicks brings in lower-quality buyers who don't stick around. We track who each piece of creative attracts, how those buyers behave after converting, and whether that quality holds as spend scales. That's what keeps your acquisition cost tied to stronger LTV, retention, and revenue quality as spend grows.

Structured message exploration

We map distinct message angles and isolate the value props behind each one, so your team can see which buying reasons deserve more spend.

Structured message exploration

We map distinct message angles and isolate the value props behind each one, so your team can see which buying reasons deserve more spend.

Structured message exploration

We map distinct message angles and isolate the value props behind each one, so your team can see which buying reasons deserve more spend.

Trusted by performance teams

“Creative Milkshake might be one of the best creative agencies I've worked with. They are quick to respond and make edits, do amazing work converting angles into solid creatives, and go above and beyond in delivering ads. I can't recommend them highly enough (especially if you're in the wellness space). It's been amazing working with the team at Creative Milkshake.”

“Creative Milkshake might be one of the best creative agencies I've worked with. They are quick to respond and make edits, do amazing work converting angles into solid creatives, and go above and beyond in delivering ads. I can't recommend them highly enough (especially if you're in the wellness space). It's been amazing working with the team at Creative Milkshake.”

Benjamin Tan,
Founder of
8Sheep Organics

Leverage the power of localization

We offer ads in English, Spanish, German, French, Dutch, Italian, and Portuguese to help you scale to new markets

Leverage the power of localization

We offer ads in English, Spanish, German, French, Dutch, Italian, and Portuguese to help you scale to new markets

Leverage the power of localization

We offer ads in English, Spanish, German, French, Dutch, Italian, and Portuguese to help you scale to new markets

Make New York paid social perform

Let’s turn better creative into stronger returns.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you work with brands outside Manhattan and across the wider NYC area?

Do you work with NYC brands that sell nationally?

How do you handle creator sourcing for NYC-based campaigns?

Do you work with regulated consumer categories based in New York?

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you work with brands outside Manhattan and across the wider NYC area?

Do you work with NYC brands that sell nationally?

How do you handle creator sourcing for NYC-based campaigns?

Do you work with regulated consumer categories based in New York?

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you work with brands outside Manhattan and across the wider NYC area?

Do you work with NYC brands that sell nationally?

How do you handle creator sourcing for NYC-based campaigns?

Do you work with regulated consumer categories based in New York?

We create data-driven ads that convert, and that’s just the start.

Stay up to date with industry insights and trends.

9490-4943 Québec inc DBA Creative Milkshake • © All Rights Reserved

We create data-driven ads that convert, and that’s just the start.

Stay up to date with industry insights and trends.

9490-4943 Québec inc DBA Creative Milkshake • © All Rights Reserved

We create data-driven ads that convert, and that’s just the start.

Stay up to date with industry insights and trends.

9490-4943 Québec inc DBA Creative Milkshake • © All Rights Reserved